When Chronic Pain Becomes Our Identity (and how to let it go)
Who are you without your pain? If you see yourself as a victim of chronic pain, know this: you are so much more than that. With practice, pain can become part of your past, not your future.
Identity plays a vital role in chronic pain recovery, especially when pain becomes who you think you are.
This article explores how the identities we attach to shape both the development and healing of chronic pain, and how detaching from them creates room to heal.
Letting go of a pain identity opens the door to healing.
When I write about Tension Myositis Syndrome (TMS), I feel compelled to tell my own story because I had symptoms of chronic pain and fatigue for three decades until I was able to recover and get back into life again. I feel like a bit of an expert.
Who Are You Without Chronic Pain?
Some people recover quickly. By understanding pain science, they may be able to reduce or eliminate their symptoms. The key to recovery is helping our survival brain feel safer; sometimes, the insight we gain from understanding why we are in pain is enough.
As most do, my healing path has taken some time. In fact, I’m still on the journey. It doesn’t end for most of us when our pain goes away. We learn a lot about ourselves, and we just keep on learning.
Identity is a major factor in the evolution of mind-body pain in TMS, and healing lies in learning the truth about who you are.
What Is Identity? (And Why It Matters for Chronic Pain Recovery)
We all have many identities or ideas about how we see ourselves. Psychology Today defines identity as “The memories, experiences, relationships, and values that create one’s sense of self. This amalgamation creates a steady sense of who one is over time, even as new facets are developed and incorporated into one’s identity.”
Common Identities That Can Fuel Chronic Pain
Here are some identities that frequently show up as pain-contributing patterns:
Achievement/performance-based identities:
The Hard Worker / Overachiever
The Perfectionist
The High Achiever ("I'm only valuable if I'm productive")
Relational/caretaking identities:
The People-Pleaser
The Peacekeeper
The Caretaker / Fixer
The Good Mom/Dad/Spouse (defined by self-sacrifice)
The Responsible One / The Reliable One
Emotional-suppression identities:
The Strong One ("I don't get to fall apart")
The Calm One (suppresses anger or conflict)
The Optimist / Positive Thinker (bypasses real emotion to "stay positive")
Self-worth/personality-based identities:
The Introvert/Extrovert (when forced to perform the "wrong" one)
The Smart One / The Dumb One
The Athletic One / The Unathletic One
The Empath (absorbing others' emotions as identity)
Pain-specific identities:
The Chronic Pain Sufferer / "Sick" Person
The Patient (defined by doctors, diagnoses, treatment-seeking)
The Support Group Member/Leader (identity reinforced by community around illness)
The Disabled Person (when disability status becomes central to self-concept)
Each one creates pressure to live up to something, and when there's a gap between the identity and how you actually feel or want to live, the nervous system reads that as unsafe. It's not the identity itself that's harmful; it's the rigidity and self-abandonment required to maintain it.
Is Your Personality Keeping You in Pain? Understanding Identity and TMS
We all carry many identities. They're not a problem until we try to live up to one that isn't true to us.
For me, that was being an introvert. Growing up with an extroverted mom, I never felt fully accepted for it, so I acted in ways that weren't true to me, just to fit in. I wasn't living authentically.
Most of us have been there. But when it becomes a way of life, it takes a toll. It's hard to feel safe when we're not living our truth — and that gap sends a danger signal straight to our survival brain.
How Identity Contributes to TMS and Neuroplastic Pain
TMS happens when our primitive brain senses threat and signals pain even without real danger. Identity plays a simple but powerful role here: when we feel pressure to measure up to who we think we should be, that pressure itself sends a danger signal to the brain.
We all unconsciously build identities we then feel bound to live up to. I mentioned being an introvert; not a problem on its own, until I attached meaning to it.
I also carried the identity of being "hard-working." That one came honestly; my dad grew up on a farm in North Dakota, up before school to feed animals with his five siblings. Hard work was instilled in him, and he passed it on to me.
Why Identities Feel Safe — Even When They Hurt Us
Sometimes our identities keep us safe. I believed that being a hard worker meant acceptance; that it would make my folks proud.
Hard work isn't the problem. It becomes unhealthy when self-care disappears, which is exactly what happened to me. When fear drives an identity, common sense often takes a back seat.
Recovering from chronic pain means recognizing where we've been living inauthentically, then realigning with our real wants, needs, and values. Many people with mind-body pain are sacrificing far more than they realize…quietly believing their own needs are selfish, or simply out of reach.
Living Authentically: The Path Out of a Pain Identity
But this is never the case. There is always a way to live our truths, and people respect us more for it. I help my clients identify what they want and need. Their truth is not their kids’, spouses’, or parents’.
You can still be a good mom, dad, or friend even when you put yourself first. You don’t have to sacrifice your truth. It’s just a habit that has been passed down. You are allowed to do it differently.
When Chronic Pain Becomes Your Identity
Pain can become an identity too. When life revolves around getting well, we join support groups, swap notes on doctors and treatments, and bond with others over shared conditions. I even ran a support group myself.
But healing is hard to do this way; it keeps reinforcing the very thing we're trying to release. And identities, even painful ones, feel safe. Giving one up can feel like giving up a part of ourselves.
We unconsciously believe our identities are us. No one wants to identify with pain, yet it can become just as hard to release as any other identity because it becomes who we think we are.
Pain became mine. I ran a support group, chased answer after answer from doctors, and spent twenty years on disability. Every part of it kept reinforcing the danger.
How to Let Go of an Identity That No Longer Serves You
It takes self-love and commitment to become aware of your beliefs about yourself. First, you must feel you are worth it, and I’m here to tell you you are. You can begin by answering these four questions:
When I sit with myself in stillness and go into my body, what do I want that I don’t have now that would make me happy? Name two or more things.
What am I doing in my life that I don’t want to do anymore? What do you want to say ‘no’ to?
Who do you want to say ‘no’ to?
What are two beliefs about yourself that aren’t serving you anymore?
How much of your identity has pain taken over?
Reclaiming Your Identity: Life After Chronic Pain
Awareness is always the first step; answering these questions will provide it. Once you can let go of the identities that no longer serve you and start living more of your truth, your life will open up in ways you never thought imaginable.
When we let go of pressure, our brains begin to feel safer. When our brains feel safe, pain is no longer needed to protect us. We stop reinforcing pain when we stop focusing on it so much.
Once I freed myself of the pressure and fear I had attached to being a hard worker, a good mom, good at this and good at that, I just became me. I’m not perfect, but I know more about what I want and need now; I know what makes me feel free and happy and what makes me feel trapped and oppressed.
I chose the former, and I hope you do too.
Please read Treating Chronic Pain Through Self-Care for a better understanding of how to recover from TMS.
For Pain Recovery Coaching, please complete our contact form or schedule a free consultation.